SAT rhetorical synthesis: why can a true answer still be wrong?
For a SAT student-notes question, consider this: Project A tracked city birds with audio recordings; Project B used photographs; both ran for six months. The goal is to emphasize a difference in methods. Why would an accurate answer about the six-month duration still be wrong?
9 Answers
It answers the wrong task: a shared duration is a similarity, not a difference in methods. A suitable answer is 'Project A tracked city birds using audio record…
Then the answer doesn't need to mention the six months at all?
Correct. Notes are material to select from, not a checklist of facts that every answer must contain. Include what helps achieve the goal. Adding all the notes c…
Would 'Project A used a more effective method than Project B' count as a stronger difference?
No. The notes do not compare effectiveness. That wording turns a difference in method into a judgment about quality. A polished sentence can still be wrong if i…
Some advice says to read the goal and skip the notes. Is that safe?
The goal is a useful starting point, but verify the selected answer against the relevant notes. A choice might sound like the right type of comparison while swa…
What if the goal changes to emphasize a similarity?
Then the shared subject or duration becomes relevant: 'Both projects tracked city birds for six months.' Try writing one sentence for each goal from the same no…