SAT comma rules: why is a comma wrong between two complete sentences?
This sentence sounds fine when read aloud: 'The team revised its model, the predictions became more accurate.' But the comma is wrong. What should replace it, and how can someone spot the same problem in a longer SAT sentence?
12 Answers
That is a comma splice: both sides can stand alone as sentences. You can write 'The team revised its model; the predictions became more accurate' or use a perio…
Wait, does that mean a comma before 'and' is always needed?
No. Compare 'The team revised its model and tested it again.' The second part has no separate subject; both actions share 'the team.' You normally would not ins…
What about 'The team revised its model, however, the predictions remained inaccurate'? Adding 'however' makes the contrast clear. Does it also fix the punctuati…
No. Compare 'The team revised its model and tested it again.' The second part has no separate subject; both actions share 'the team.' You normally would not ins…
What about 'The team revised its model, however, the predictions remained inaccurate'? Adding 'however' makes the contrast clear. Does it also fix the punctuati…
The contrast works, but the comma splice remains. 'However' is not a coordinating conjunction. Write 'The team revised its model; however, the predictions remai…
The contrast works, but the comma splice remains. 'However' is not a coordinating conjunction. Write 'The team revised its model; however, the predictions remai…
That explains why choosing punctuation by how a sentence sounds can go wrong. What is the quickest structure check?
Find the subject and main verb on each side. Here: team + revised; predictions + became. Then ask whether either side begins with a dependent word such as 'beca…
A useful mistake-log entry would be 'I treated however like and.' That is much more specific than 'punctuation mistake.'
Try the check on this variation: 'Because the team revised its model, the predictions improved.' The comma is appropriate because the opening clause is dependen…