How to decide to pick between noun and a pronoun
In 'The observatory displayed the images on its website,' why does 'its' refer to the observatory rather than 'images,' which is closer? How do we decide what a pronoun replaces instead of just picking the nearest noun?
9 Answers
Follow the meaning: the website belongs to the observatory, not to the images. The singular possessive 'its' matches that antecedent. For SAT pronoun agreement,…
Would 'their website' work if we meant the staff at the observatory?
You would need wording that establishes the staff as the intended antecedent. The sentence as written names the observatory, so 'its website' is the straightfor…
And 'it's website' fails because the apostrophe makes it a contraction?
Exactly. Expand it: 'it is website' or 'it has website' does not fit. 'Its' is possessive without an apostrophe, unlike a noun such as 'the observatory's websit…
What if agreement is fine but the reference is unclear? 'Maya told Lena that she had won' could mean either person.
That is an ambiguity problem. If Maya won, write 'Maya told Lena about her own victory' or otherwise name Maya clearly. If Lena won, make that explicit instead.…
Should a review note say 'wrong pronoun' or name the specific problem?
Name the problem: unclear antecedent, number mismatch, or contraction confused with possession. Also avoid the blanket rule that singular 'they' is wrong; it ha…