SAT dangling modifiers: why can a sentence sound right but be wrong?
'After analyzing the soil samples, the results were recorded by the scientist.' This sounds normal at first. Is it actually saying that the results analyzed the samples? What is the cleanest way to fix it?
9 Answers
The opening phrase attaches to 'the results,' the subject that follows, so the sentence has a dangling modifier. Write 'After analyzing the soil samples, the sc…
But the original still includes 'by the scientist.' Why doesn't that solve the problem?
Because it names the scientist later without changing the subject of the main clause. The opening phrase still has the wrong attachment. Moving the correct pers…
Would 'After the scientist analyzed the samples, the results were recorded' also work?
Yes. The opening clause now contains its own subject and verb. It no longer relies on the next clause's subject to tell us who analyzed the samples. Passive voi…
Does the rule apply to descriptions without an obvious action, like 'Built in 1920'?
It does. 'Built in 1920, the bridge still carries traffic' correctly describes the bridge. 'Built in 1920, commuters still use the bridge' would wrongly attach …
So adding a comma cannot rescue the second version. The noun after it is the issue.
Right. A useful practice note is 'Who or what does the opening phrase describe?' Answer that before reading the choices. If the sentence names the right person …