How to use comma
The usual advice is 'remove the extra information and see if the sentence still works.' But these both sound grammatical: 'The telescope that has an infrared sensor is reserved' and 'The telescope is reserved.' Does that mean the longer version needs commas?
8 Answers
Not necessarily. 'That has an infrared sensor' may identify which telescope is reserved, so it is essential to the intended meaning. A shorter sentence can be g…
What would a clearly nonessential example look like?
'The telescope, which was installed last spring, captures distant galaxies.' The installation date adds information about the telescope rather than identifying …
If the blank appears after 'spring,' could a semicolon close the interruption?
No. The opening comma needs the matching closing comma here. A semicolon would also separate the subject from its main verb, 'captures,' rather than join two in…
Names make this harder. Is 'the astronomer Maya Chen' always written without commas?
No universal rule. Compare 'The astronomer Maya Chen spoke first' with 'Maya Chen, an astronomer, spoke first.' In the first, the name identifies the astronomer…
So 'a name needs commas' and 'a name never needs commas' are both shortcuts to avoid.